Happy B-Day to our dedicated webmaster! Glad to hear TEMERITY has escaped the boat hospital.
Many are familiar with legendary seaman (Warwick) Commodore Tompkins. Commodore grew up afloat on the German pilot schooner WANDERBIRD, and has probably sailed and raced more miles than anyone alive.
Commodore is the only one I know who has singlehanded a WylieCat 30 back from Hawaii sans autopilot or windvane. That's confidence in being able to balance the sail plan so the boat steers on its own.
For the last five years, Commodore and wife Nancy have been cruising their custom Wylie 39 FLASHGIRL in the South Pacific and have homeported in the Bay of Islands, New Zealand.
Now they are headed home to SF Bay, via Tonga, French Polynesia, the Marquesas, and Hawaii. Commodore has great confidence and no fear of sailing upwind. FLASHGIRL has water ballast, a tall rig, is close winded, and fast on all points of sail.
For some reason Commodore chose to approach a dangerous section of the Tuamotus, "the Dangerous Archipelago," relying on a chartplotter, and carrying only one small scale chart. At night.
The Tuamotus are low atolls, nothing higher than a palm tree, with dubious charting, steep-to reefs, strong and unpredictable currents, and visible 5-7 miles in good conditions during daylight. Even with modern navigation, many vessels have been wrecked in the Tuamotus, most notably Sterling Hayden's classic schooner WANDERER on the SE corner of Rangiroa, during a night time passage.
Here is Commodore's recent account:
~~~~~~~~/)~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
FLASHGIRL'S sail from Fakarava to Makemo
FLASHGIRL was anchored in Hirifa, the SE corner of Fakarava for a week, waiting for the fresh easterlies to subside. Hirifa is a broad sweep of coral sand backed by the low scrub and coconut palms typical of the Tuamotu atolls. The shallow waters near the beach liberally sprinkled with coral heads give way to deeper water where all the yachts were anchored. This anchorage had anywhere from 3-7 yachts at any given time. In this anchorage, the colors were spectacular. Water deeper than ten meters was a rich sapphire blue, while the shoals up to the beach were a vivid green and then the white of the coral sand and the green of the bush and the coconut trees topped by the beautiful pure blue of the sky and the white of the clouds. There were almost no inhabitants at this part of the island, hence, no lights at night save those of the anchored yachts. No roads, no cars, no noise at all. The only sound to be heard was the booming of the surf of the sea side of this atoll. This was a near perfect anchorage and one tended to stay longer than initially planned.
Many of the yachts, including us, intended to visit more eastern atolls enroute to the Marquesas, some 600 miles to the NE. In consequence of these plans, there was nearly daily sharing of weather information and predictions. Cruising vessels we have encountered have varying degrees of sailing capability. There is a strong tendency among this group to avoid headwinds and seas. During the last days of our visit in Hirifa, the collected wisdom was that there would be a shift from east to NE to N and finally NW and diminishing to calm. Welcome news indeed.
We awoke on FLASHGIRL the following morning and noticed immediately that the wind had shifted into the NE about a day prior to the prediction. An expedition went out to the windward shore to check the sea state, actual wind direction and velocity. This party returned with encouraging news. We in FLASHGIRL recognized the opportunity and quickly got the boat ready to leave. FLASHGIRL recovered her anchor within the hour and headed for the South Pass, eight miles away. There was some talk about swimming through this pass which is famous for its underwater beauty. On arrival at the pass, however, there seemed to be too much wind and flooding current to make swimming attractive. Accordingly, FLASHGIRL departed the pass about an hour after the flood began, at which time there was about 2.5 knots of current. We hoisted the mainsail and prepared the staysail inside the pass. We cleared the pass at 10:45.
It was bright and sunny, the wind direction was about 60 degrees magnetic at 18 knots and the sea was moderate. FLASHGIRL with a full ballast, full main and staysail was recording 6.5 to 7 knots with an apparent wind angle of 32 degrees.
The atoll of Tahanea lies approximately twelve miles east of the South Pass in Fakarava. We were able to fetch Tahanea with about four miles to spare. We sailed the length of Tahanea on port tack, the tops of the palms readily visible to leeward. The wind was steady and varied between 14 and 19 knots. FLASHGIRL found herself at the eastern end of Tahanea as night fell, with the prospect of negotiating four unlit atolls at night with no moon and overcast. Starboard tack at that point yielded magnetic north and the GPS position indicated we had forty miles to go on starboard before running into the south side of an atoll named Katiu.
Many of the atolls in the Tuamotu Archipelago have wooded motus on their eastern and northern shores, while the southern part of the atoll is frequently a reef, awash. In the area we were navigating, there were no lights on anything. We were faced with the prospect of tacking through these islands with no visibility whatsoever. A further feature of these atolls is that the reef rises very near vertically from the depths to the reef awash. This feature means that the fathometer is of little or no help in avoiding such a reef.
As FLASHGIRL reached the point on starboard tack where prudence suggested a tack onto port, we decided instead to take in the mainsail and jog slowly under staysail alone, first west, then east in the smooth water lee of Katiu. Our GPS position indicated we were leaving Katiu a respectful three miles to windward. In this location the sea was smooth and FLASHGIRL was pleasant. The smoothness of the sea was both pleasing and mildly alarming, it could only mean that the reef was not awfully far distant. Having found errors of land masses and GPS location in the order of a quarter of a mile, and being acutely aware of capricious currents, anything closer than a calculated three miles we deemed hazardous. We were somewhat comforted by being able to see through the mist and haze of the night, occasional glimpses of lights from the village noted on the far, or windward side of the lagoon. Bearings taken on these lights, lent credence to our GPS plots, which was reassuring. It was during our starboard tack approach to Katiu, that our electronic navigational system packed it in. This meant that our sole remaining navigational aids were a paper chart covering a vast area of the Tuamotu Archipelago and the GPS. Radar would have been of no use whatsoever, as reefs awash do not return an echo. Waiting for daylight in what we considered was a safe location was the best recourse. On this occasion, we sailed west, under staysail for two hours and then east for three hours, the autopilot doing the work and the staysail with just enough drive for two knots of boat speed. In this situation, the wind was approximately over the beam on both tacks.
As dawn approached, FLASHGIRL encountered increasing wave action, suggesting we were approaching the eastern end of Katiu, still no visibility. Mindful of the distance we had to go in order to get into Makemo, our destination, we elected to continue in our easterly direction, and hoisted the mainsail at the very first light. The wind by now had shifted almost fifty degrees and was blowing close to north magnetic. This made for a close, comfortable reach on the plotted course of 55 degrees magnetic. This port tack should have been four hours to clear the west corner of Makemo. About an hour before the west end was under our lee, we were forced to make a twenty degree alteration to windward putting us hard on the wind. Ultimately we were forced to motor sail for a mile or two in order to get comfortable offing. Near the north and west corner of Makemo, there is a pass into the interior of the lagoon. When we went past this opening less than a mile offshore, it was ebbing hard, causing a turbulent sea, probably 5-6 knots of ebb and 20 knots of wind opposing it. This combination of elements was also exacerbated by a strong southerly set, the result of the northerly wind. This southerly set, accounted for the need for our radical course change in the passage between Katiu and Makemo in the early morning hours. Such a current, unpredictable and unannounced, is a good example of why they call this group of islands, "the dangerous archipelago".
Once clear of this NW corner, we were able to ease sheets and beam and broad reach the next thirty miles down the windward coast of Makemo. We had the same general wind velocity of about eighteen knots, a still modest sea and dazzling sunlight with large puffy clouds. The windward coast of Makemo with its hungry surf, lay about a mile to leeward. We were anxious to reach what is called the Eastern Pass close to slack water. In the interests of speed we hoisted our best reaching sail, and savored an exhilarating three sail reach booming down this shore at about 8 or 9 knots. In these conditions, we carried a full tank of ballast and the boat is bolt upright and has feather light helm. The only thing missing on this little ride, was surfing!
We had sufficient speed over this course to arrive at the Eastern Pass at 11:45, about an hour after the flood began. There was impressive surf breaking on the visible coral on both sides of the pass. With the wind well aft, we broad reached into the pass, carrying the full mainsail, our red reaching headsail and lamenting the lack of a photographer. It is always exciting to transit these passes, the close proximity of the breaking sea and frightening coral is a stimulating and unforgettable experience. We found a wide spot in the channel as we entered, probably doing ten knots over the bottom, and doused the red sail without getting it wet. We ran on downwind for half a mile, rounded up under power, and lowered the mainsail. With the mainsail stowed, we motored into and surveyed the anchorage just to the west of the pass. The bottom in this anchorage is sand, studded liberally with coral heads.
There were seven yachts involved in some sort of rally, already lying in this anchorage, preparing to leave. We found a place with 11 meters of water where we thought the anchor would hold in sand and the chain not become too fouled in the coral. Mercifully the water is very clear in this anchorage. No sooner were we anchored, when someone from the rally motored over to us. Their mission was to ask if we were going to accompany them when they left in the next hour or so. We answered in the negative of course, having only just arrived. The rally person seemed quite disappointed that we were not going to sail with the fleet. There must be some kind of herd instinct at work with these groups. As we watched this fleet prepare for departure, we noticed an approaching squall of major proportions. Evidently, whoever was calling the shots in the rally, failed to notice or did not understand the significance of this long low black cloud. In the event, all seven boats recovered their anchors and made off for the pass. Very quickly after leaving the anchorage, the squall was upon us, gusting 30 knots with rain. We were treated to the spectacle of these forlorn cruisers first entering the pass and then reversing their course. They returned en masse to the anchorage and reanchored. The only explanation we could imagine for this bizarre behavior was an over arching desire to exit the lagoon with the ebb tide. This conviction of course overlooked the fact that across wind and tide in one of these lagoon passes results in large standing waves. In this particular instance, they were planning to negotiate a narrow pass with likely a six knot current setting into the teeth of a thirty knot squall. The exiting yachts would be required in this circumstance, to motor directly into the standing waves and wind. Mercifully no harm came to anyone and about half of the fleet ultimately escaped the lagoon.
For FLASHGIRL the Fakarava to Makemo run was very gratifying. We didn't hit anything and had a romping great sail!