The balanced lug rig is a good rig. Now, the way I see it, there's a community of "alternative" boat nuts who just hate bermudan rigs and love lugs. They're gotten so hardnosed about it that now there's a reverse snobbery thing going on. .... to be in the cool peoples club, your boat HAS to have a lug rig of some kind. A distant second place which will leave you with associated club membership status is a sprit rig,but anything that looks bermudan is just bad, bad, bad.
Once, before I bought the S2 7.9, I was down at the Alameda Marina, at the end of the small boat dock, the dock farthest west. Some homeless guy had stripped the Cal 20 that he was living on of everything metal..mast, winches, blocks, gudgeons...mast base... jib tracks, EVERYTHING, and cut it loose in the Estuary. It had drifted over to the Alameda Marina, where a tenant had kept it from beating up on some boats there, and tied it off to the end of the dock.
I seriously considered picking it up...getting an aluminum tube (3-inch diameter straight tube, 20 feet long is about $80 at Allan Steel in Redwood City) and turning a mast base and masthead fitting out of hard maple, on a wood lathe. A few more pieces of wood, and a cut-down secondhand mainsail....some old blocks...make a new rudder out of a 2 x 12 and voila...I'm "big boat" sailing again for cheap.
I didn't do it, but there are days.....
Once, before I bought the S2 7.9, I was down at the Alameda Marina, at the end of the small boat dock, the dock farthest west. Some homeless guy had stripped the Cal 20 that he was living on of everything metal..mast, winches, blocks, gudgeons...mast base... jib tracks, EVERYTHING, and cut it loose in the Estuary. It had drifted over to the Alameda Marina, where a tenant had kept it from beating up on some boats there, and tied it off to the end of the dock.
I seriously considered picking it up...getting an aluminum tube (3-inch diameter straight tube, 20 feet long is about $80 at Allan Steel in Redwood City) and turning a mast base and masthead fitting out of hard maple, on a wood lathe. A few more pieces of wood, and a cut-down secondhand mainsail....some old blocks...make a new rudder out of a 2 x 12 and voila...I'm "big boat" sailing again for cheap.
I didn't do it, but there are days.....